Advising with empathy and experience

Hospital trust computer error lost 24,000 patient letters


A hospital trust failed to send out 24,000 letters from senior doctors to patients and their GPs after they became lost in a new computer system.

Newcastle Hospitals warned the problem, dating back to 2018, is significant. The BBC said that it was told the problems occurred when letters requiring sign-off from a senior doctor were placed into a folder few staff knew existed.

Most of the letters explain what should happen when patients are discharged from hospital but a significant number were written by specialist clinics detailing the care that patients require. It means that patients may not have had some crucial tests and results.

Staff at the hospital have been told to record any resulting incidents of patient harm and ensure these are addressed.

Following a routine inspection by health and care regulator, the Care Quality Commission (CQC), staff at the trust raised concerns about delays in sending out correspondence.

A subsequent review of all the trust's consultants revealed that most had unsent letters in their electronic records.

A source at Newcastle Hospitals told the BBC that consultants had raised issues about the electronic patient record system for years, complaining it was slow and hard to use, but had not been listened to.

In a letter to staff about the problem, seen by the BBC, the Newcastle Trust explained that letters drafted by one member of staff have to be signed off by a second clinician, who must change their user status to "signing clinician", before they can be sent.

If that doesn't happen, letters end up in a consultant's document folder and remain unsent until they are signed off correctly.

The CQC's interim director of operations in the North, Sarah Dronsfield, said: "We took immediate action to request further detail from the trust to understand the extent to which people may be at risk, and evidence of the steps being taken to review the impact on patients, ensure people are safe and mitigate any risk of avoidable delays in treatment going forward."

She said the trust had submitted an action plan and volunteered to provide weekly updates on its progress against that plan.

The trust says it will immediately deal with a 6,000-letter backlog from the last year alone. More than 1,200 of these relate to medicine and emergency care. Some letters may be duplicates, or created in error.

In a separate letter seen by the BBC, Newcastle Hospitals told senior doctors that the CQC was worried about the impact on patients.

GP and chairman of the North East BMA Council, Dr George Rae, said there would be "an incredible amount of information" within the letters. He said: "If you didn't get the letters, you wouldn't have the results of scans, X-rays or blood tests" and that GPs would be "absolutely unaware" of a change in medication or treatment if a patient had gone to hospital and received a significant diagnosis.

Newcastle Hospitals' chief operating officer, Martin Wilson, said he wanted to reassure patients that "we are taking immediate steps to address the issue.”

The hospital trust said it was working to understand if there had been any impact to ongoing care and treatment of patients. It is currently reviewing 24,000 documents from its electronic records, which accounts for less than 0.3% of all contact with patients, the trust says.

Mr Wilson added: “If any concerns are identified, we will inform patients and their GPs directly. We are taking this issue very seriously and are working quickly to put things right."

The CQC said it was monitoring the trust closely and could inspect it at any time if it had concerns.

It said: "We will report on the full findings from our latest inspection and any areas where the trust has been required to make improvements as soon as we are able to. If anyone has any concerns about the care they have received they can let us know directly.